Welcome to PrestoFresh

Presto Fresh orders are filled by Zagara’s team members. Trained to properly pick only the freshest produce and best hand-cut meats and seafood, the Zagara’s Presto Fresh team will have your order ready for pick-up or delivery.

Large Halloween Pumpkins - $3.98!  


Tombstone Pizza

Online Only - While Supplies Last!   Was  $5.99  Now  $2.49



 How to change an Existing Order

If you have a pending order and wish to add or delete items, send email to mskinner@zmp1936.  Include the items that you want to add or delete, and we will change your order and adjust the charge for you.

How to Use “Presto Points”

 Whenever you place an order, you accumulate “Presto Points.”  These points are redeemable for discounts on future orders.  

Every $10 you spend earns you 100 points.  Every 10,000 points you redeem saves you $10.

You will see your points balance at the top right of your screen It looks like this:

 You redeem your points while checking out.  Before entering your credit/debit card information, select the box “Spend Your Points.”  You will then be able to redeem your points in multiples of 10,000.  (Minimum redemption is 10,000 points.)  Find the box that looks like this:

 Contact mskinner@zmp1936.com for any questions about “Presto Points.”


Scroll to the Bottom of this Page for New and On-Sale Items!



Need help? Call us at 844-264-8881

Order & Delivery Details

Free Services

Heights-Area Delivery

In-Store Pickup

Minimum Order


Orders cannot be adjusted

Item Refunds


Items not delivered refunded next business day



844.261.8881 or 216.321.6358

Must be registered and logged in to receive free services and discount.

Free delivery to: Cleveland’s east side, University Circle, Little Italy, Beachwood, Lyndhurst, Mayfield Village, South Euclid and Pepper Pike and the “Heights” including Cleveland, Shaker, Mayfield, University, Richmond, Warrensville.

Communities outside of a 7.5 mile radius from 1940 Lee Road, Cleveland Heights are subject to a fee as high as $30.  Communities outside a 10 mile radius cannot receive a delivery.

New Products

You have been logged out due to inactivity. Please log in to continue shopping from where you left off!
Click Here to login

Please wait...

Product has been added to cart .
Product has been removed .